Home’s where the hearth is.

(Pencilthat cosy Hobbit gamereleasing next year into your diaries.)

You venture forth to find the rest of the expedition, uncovering the secrets of Moria along the way.

The Lord of the Rings: Return to Moria artwork showing three dwarves in a cave standing on a large rock

It’s a combination that works so well, you wonder why nobody thought of it before.

The dwarves are renowned for their mining and metalworking skills, making them great protagonists for a survival-crafting game.

Yet this is a game with problems.

Cover image for YouTube video

Within each of these regions, however, there is plenty of freedom to explore.

The environments are gorgeous and surprisingly varied considering the entire game takes place underground.

Some of the locations were so unexpected that I couldn’t help but gasp when entering a new area.

LOTR Return to Moria screenshot - A dwarf stands to the right, with customisation options and sliders on the left. This page shows the ability to pick your dwarf’s personality, voice and origin.

I found myself gleefully fangirling over hobbit crockery, and reverently observing some of the more sombre locations.

You explore one place down in the oppressive depths, then are lifted back up again to somewhere brighter.

Respite comes, too, in the form of setting up camp and building cosy hideaways in the darkness.

LOTR Return to Moria screenshot - A dwarf stands in the middle of a darkened corridor, lighting the way with a torch. There are skeletons and orc arrows at the sides of the path.

For this reason, food planning becomes vitally important.

Moments of lightness are also found through singing - another staple of Tolkien’s books, of course.

(It’s also a clever form of distraction when mining ore veins.)

LOTR Return to Moria gif - A gif showing a dwarf walking through the lower areas of the Mines of Moria, with the camera slowly moving upwards to show the dizzying heights of the scaffolding above

The process of discovery just becomesbetterwhen you have someone else to experience it with.

Naturally, we climbed down to investigate.

We then had what can only be called an ‘unpleasant encounter’ with a lumbering fiery beast.

LOTR Return to Moria screenshot - A dwarf stands in the centre of the screen, regarding a cave troll that has been turned into stone by the sunlight.

Terrified and screaming, we dashed back up the ladders again.

Only one of us made it.

The building system also leaves a fair bit to be desired.

LOTR Return to Moria screenshot - One of Return to Moria’s food crafting menus. This one, for the late-game stove, shows options for cooking items such as Meat Pie, Tagine and Krumkake.

Balancing issues also become a problem at certain points of the game, particularly when playing solo.

I have never heard the word “brutalise” so many times in a week.

The same post reveals further usability improvements to come for things like inventory management and gathering items.

LOTR Return to Moria gif - Two dwarves stand in a player-built tavern, holding mugs of ale while singing and dancing. One dwarf has the tankard on her head, the other swings his mug from side to side.

For fans of Middle-earth this is worth experiencing, particularly if someone else joins you for the adventure.

So if you’re willing to forgive the jank: add friend, and enter.

LOTR Return to Moria screenshot - In the foreground a dwarf faces the camera, while in the background another player can be seen climbing a ladder. They are in a cavern of stone, surrounded by glowing mushrooms.